Engineers usually know they need solder paste inspection long before the purchase is approved. The gap is a business case that finance will accept. This article walks through how to build one from numbers you already have, without leaning on anyone else’s headline statistics.
Start with what defects cost you today
You need four figures from your own line. If you do not track them exactly, a conservative estimate is better than a borrowed number.
- Boards built per year.
- First-pass yield, or its inverse: the percentage of boards that need rework.
- Average cost to rework a board: labor time at a loaded rate, plus materials and retest.
- Scrap: the percentage of boards that cannot be recovered, and what a board is worth at that point.
Multiply them out. A line building 250,000 boards a year with 3% rework at $25 per board spends $187,500 a year on rework alone, before scrap, before test escapes and before anyone counts the engineering time spent chasing intermittent faults.
Estimate the share that is print-related
SPI only helps with defects that originate in printing. Pull a month of rework tickets and classify them. Opens, insufficient solder, bridges on fine-pitch parts, solder balls and many tombstones are print-related. Wrong parts and damaged components are not.
Use your own split. If you have no data at all, the commonly quoted industry range is that well over half of solder defects start at the printer, but a number from your own tickets will survive scrutiny far better.
Be honest about the reduction
No inspection system removes every print-related defect. How much it removes depends on how you use it. A benchtop system used to qualify setups and sample during the run catches setup errors and slow drift. A fully automatic system measuring every board also catches the random bad print. In both cases the reduction is larger if someone acts on the trend data.
Model a conservative case and an expected case rather than a single optimistic figure. A business case that still works with a modest improvement is one that gets approved.
Add the costs, all of them
- Purchase price of the system.
- Installation and any line changes.
- Operator and engineer training time.
- Annual calibration, service and software costs.
- The operator time to run it, if it is a manual system.
Ask the supplier about recurring charges in particular. Annual software licenses and mandatory service contracts change the five-year picture considerably.
Calculate payback and five-year return
| Line item | Formula |
|---|---|
| Annual rework savings | boards x rework rate x expected reduction x rework cost |
| Annual scrap savings | boards x defect rate x expected reduction x scrap share x board value |
| Net annual savings | rework savings + scrap savings - annual operating cost |
| Payback (months) | total investment / net annual savings x 12 |
| Five-year ROI | (5 x net annual savings - investment) / investment |
Our ROI calculator does this arithmetic for you and lets you change every assumption.
Benefits that are real but harder to price
Leave these out of the headline number and list them separately. They strengthen the case without exposing it to argument.
- Faster new product introduction, because print setup is verified by measurement instead of trial builds.
- Fewer field failures from marginal joints that pass test and fail later.
- Objective data for customer audits and for supplier discussions about stencils and paste.
- Capacity released when rework operators and stations are no longer the bottleneck.
Presenting it
Keep the case to one page: current annual cost of print-related defects, the conservative and expected savings, total investment, payback in months. Attach the rework ticket analysis as evidence. Decision makers approve cases built from their own plant’s numbers much more readily than cases built from a brochure.