IPC-A-610, Acceptability of Electronic Assemblies, is the most widely used workmanship standard in electronics manufacturing. It defines what an acceptable finished assembly looks like, and it does so for three product classes. The class your customer specifies determines how tight your process has to be, and therefore how much you need to measure.
The three classes
| Class | Name | Typical products |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | General electronic products | Consumer goods where function is the main requirement |
| 2 | Dedicated service electronic products | Industrial, communications and business equipment where extended life and uninterrupted service are desired |
| 3 | High performance / harsh environment electronic products | Medical life support, aerospace, defense and other equipment that must work on demand |
How Class 3 differs from Class 2
The defect categories are largely the same. What changes is the threshold. Class 3 generally allows less component overhang off the pad, requires more complete solder fillets and wetting, requires more complete fill of plated through-holes, and treats some conditions that are acceptable or “process indicators” in Class 2 as defects.
Always work from the current revision of the standard itself for specific criteria. Requirements are revised, and the customer’s contract may add to them.
What the standard does and does not require
IPC-A-610 describes the acceptance criteria for the finished product. It does not tell you which inspection equipment to use or where to put it. Its companion, J-STD-001, covers the materials and process requirements for soldering. Solder paste printing has its own guidance in IPC-7527, and stencil design in IPC-7525.
In other words, the class defines the target. How you hit it reliably is up to you.
What this means for inspection
Tighter acceptance criteria mean a narrower process window. With less tolerance for a marginal joint, variation that Class 2 would absorb becomes rework in Class 3. Three practical consequences follow.
- Measure earlier. With less margin at the end, controlling paste volume at the start matters more.
- Measure more. Sampling plans that are adequate for Class 2 may leave too much unverified for Class 3.
- Keep records. High-reliability customers commonly expect objective evidence that the process was in control, per lot or per board.
Rework is a bigger problem in Class 3
High-reliability customers often restrict rework, require it to be documented, or limit the number of times a location can be reworked. That raises the value of getting it right first time, and of finding print problems while the fix is still a wipe and reprint.
Related quality system standards
- ISO 13485 for medical devices.
- AS9100 for aerospace.
- IATF 16949 for automotive.
These govern the quality management system, not the solder joint, but each expects measurement systems to be capable and calibrated, and processes to be controlled with data. An inspection system with a documented GR&R and stored results helps to show both.